Here is a look at the mayoral race, as sent to our subscribers this afternoon. (You can join our subscriber list on the right side of this page.)
Mayoral Race Shapes Up
The race for mayor has shaped up, but it certainly has not heated up. With election day exactly three weeks from today, the race has settled into a lopsided contest with Bill de Blasio leading Joe Lhota by 40 to 50 points in public opinion polls. As de Blasio and Lhota meet tonight in their first televised debate, Lhota desperately needs to shake up the race.
Although the consistently lopsided polls paint the race as finished and predictable, a close watching of what the candidates are saying reveals many unexpected moments. For example – which candidate said this?
“What we need to do to deal with income inequality, which we have in this city, is talking about what programs we’re going to have to be able to deal with the income inequality, how we’re going to make New York affordable, how we’re going to make affordable housing more plentiful in the City of New York.” It was Republican Joe Lhota. Continue reading Mayoral Race Shapes Up→
On Friday Joe Lhota and Assembly Member Joe Borelli held a press conference calling on the City to allow Staten Island drivers to use roads inside the now-closed Fresh Kills landfill. Fresh Kills was closed in 2001 and is presently being developed as an eco-park.
Opening roads for local drivers, who endure heavy traffic congestion, is an appealing issue for Lhota. It highlights his deep deficit in the race, however, as he’s fighting on what should be his turf both geographically and topically, rather than on Bill de Blasio’s turf.
Here’s our look at Lhota’s battle.
Here is complete video of the press conference held by Joe Lhota and Assembly Member Joe Borelli.
Tonight Republican mayoral candidate Joe Lhota and Independence Party mayoral candidate Adolfo Carrion participated in a mayoral candidate debate hosted by NY1. Bill de Blasio was invited, but declined to attend.
Topics that Lhota addressed following the debate include whether his idea of switching MTA Bridges & Tunnels to City control has any chance of state approval, his view of Mayor Bloomberg’s resiliency planning, charter schools and his reaction to a WSJ story describing Ken Langone, one of Lhota’s strongest supporters, as “convinced” that Lhota will lose. Here is Joe Lhota’s full press availability following the debate.
Update – Carrion:
Following the debate, Adolfo Carrion spoke with the press concerning Bill de Blasio’s absence, terming his absence a message of “disrespect to the voters.” Carrion also discussed voter interest and turnout.
In recent days, Joe Lhota has discussed the Affordable Care Act, Obamacare, on several occasions. His primary focus has been to denounce House Republicans for demanding defunding of Obamacare in exchange for ending the federal government shutdown. While doing so, however, Lhota has repeatedly returned to a discredited notion: that health care, and health insurance, reform isn’t really necessary because all New Yorkers have access to health care via hospital emergency rooms. It’s a point that many elected Republicans, George W. Bush and Mitt Romney among them, have tried to make.
In reality, the fact that many Americans have hospital emergency rooms as their only health care option is one of the big drivers of the need for broad changes in our health care system. So-called “free riders” who use, but don’t pay for, the health care system, are an enormous financial burden to insureds and taxpayers. The problem is exacerbated by the frequent situation that free riders tend to not have access to preventative care, and only seek health care in a hospital emergency room once they’ve developed a serious condition, resulting in higher costs. Those higher costs are, of course, borne by others.
So yes, it’s true that we provide health care to all via our public hospitals. But it’s not true that it’s free. Paying for those unable to pay or obtain insurance themselves is part of the problem, not the solution.
That’s the Rev. Al Sharpton and Republican mayoral candidate Joe Lhota. Joe Lhota, along with Bill de Blasio and many other elected officials and candidates, went to the National Action Network’s House of Justice to celebrate Rev. Sharpton’s birthday. (Lhota had visited the House of Justice for a private meeting with Rev. Sharpton about three weeks ago – our report is here.) Here’s Rev. Sharpton introducing Lhota and Lhota’s full presentation.
Today Bill de Blasio sought to refine his fiscal self-description to “fiscally responsible progressive.” Speaking on Friday to business leaders at an ABNY breakfast, de Blasio described himself as a “fiscal conservative.” That description was a surprise to some, but it goes to de Blasio’s possible electoral vulnerability of being portrayed as a wild-eyed spendthrift. When I asked de Blasio about his “fiscal conservative” self-characterization today, he responded with the refined term and offered a lengthy description of how achieving his goals will require fiscal responsibility, saying that there’s “no contradiction between good fiscal management and an activist government.”
Joe Lhota went on the attack against Bill de Blasio today, as a new Quinnipiac poll showed de Blasio with an enormous lead.
Dana Rubenstein of Capital New York asked Lhota for his view of how Governor Cuomo’s newly announced tax commission, with the assigned mission of finding taxes to cut, affects de Blasio’s signature proposal of funding universal pre-K with an increased income tax on high earners. Lhota responded by launching into a harsh critique of de Blasio as “essentially a political hack who has no no plans for the future”, and characterizing de Blasio’s stated lack of a “Plan B” if his tax proposal does not received needed state legislative/gubernatorial approval as showing “management immaturity.”
Today Bill de Blasio continued seeking to define Joe Lhota as part and parcel of the radical wing currently dominating the national Republicans, the Tea Party House Republicans. de Blasio has been hitting that theme for a few days, seeking to define Lhota at a moment where Lhota is still fairly unknown and the Tea Party House Republicans, as the deeply unpopular face of the Republican political brand, are in the national spotlight.
Yesterday, Lhota tried to avoid being linked to the House Republicans, condemning them for the federal government shutdown and calling it “outrageous and wrong”. He also described the Tea Party as a “bad force” in the Republican Party.
Today, responding to a question from Politicker’sRoss Barkan, de Blasio continued his effort, describing the current Republican Party as “a very right wing party” and saying of Lhota that “if you’re a member of the Republican Party, you’re buying into the whole idea.” Team de Blasio smells political blood, and appears focused on framing this city race through the lens of Washington shutdown politics.
Today Joe Lhota responded to reporters’ questions about the federal government shutdown by condemning the shutdown and the House Republicans, describing the shutdown as “flat out wrong.” Lhota also more broadly condemned the Tea Party and it’s influence on the Republican Party.
When I asked about the paradox of condemning the Tea Party but receiving large amounts of money from one of the Tea Party’s most prominent financial backers, David Koch, Lhota responded strongly. He noted Koch’s many philanthropic endeavors and said that he, like Koch and Bill de Blasio, believes in abortion rights and marriage equality. Lhota also pointed to Andrew Cuomo having received (according to Lhota) $81,000 from Koch and his wife, asserting that taking Koch’s money did not make Lhota any more of a tea party supporter than doing so made Andrew Cuomo a tea party supporter.
The Democratic race for Public Advocate came to a close Monday night as the two remaining candidates attended their last joint forum. Letitia James and Daniel Squadron addressed the Bayswater Civic Association, in the Bayswater section of Rockaway. They spoke separately, crossing paths briefly. Squadron arrived toward the end of James’ presentation, sitting quietly in the audience. As James left, they exchanged smiles and a quick wave.
We spoke separately with each, asking the same two questions: First, your thoughts as you close out the last night of a long campaign? Second, your thoughts on the ugly turn in the race? Here’s what they had to say.
We began our coverage of the Public Advocate’s race at the first candidate forum, held in Astoria in February, available here. We have lots of coverage since then, available here.
Mayoral candidate Bill de Blasio visited Rockaway yesterday, touring the closed Peninsula Hospital, visiting a family who continues to work on post-Sandy repairs to their home and attending a forum hosted by Faith in New York at St. Mary Star of the Sea in Far Rockaway. Although Rockaway has progressed greatly in recovering from Sandy, much work remains. Many residents and businesses continue repairing their damaged property and reorganizing their lives as the city and federal governments repair infrastructure and contemplate future steps.
Rockaway has long had severe financial and social stresses, with some sections as rough and impoverished as any in the city. Those rougher sections of Rockaway happen to have an ocean beach, but they’re weighed down by the same troubles as neighborhoods in less bucolic locations. Everyone in Rockaway, whatever their economic status, race and ethnicity or political views, was severely affected by Sandy and has faced great challenges in struggling to recover. Unsurprisingly, however, those on the down side of Rockaway’s long standing economic and social fault lines faced Sandy with the least; the least money, the least ability to relocate, the least political influence, the fewest options, and have been the slowest to recover. It was this part of Rockaway that de Blasio visited yesterday.
Press Q & A:
Following the forum, de Blasio spoke with the press.
Here are two excerpts covering Rockaway-specific questions. The first, from Kevin Boyle of The Wave, addresses the dramatic increases in flood insurance resulting from the Biggert-Waters Act.
The second, from Katie Honan of DNAinfo and co-founder of Rockaway Help, addresses the hospital crisis in Rockaway following the closing of Peninsula Hospital and the current stress on Rockaway’s sole remaining hospital, St. John’s Episcopal.
Here is de Blasio’s full Q&A with the press, including his opening statement describing his visit.
Update – Forum on Sandy Recovery:
In his remarks at the forum on Hurricane Sandy recovery, hosted by Faith In New York, de Blasio called for an expansive use of Sandy recovery money. He advocated addressing many of Rockaway’s long standing social and economic issues, calling it “our obligation … to figure out how much good we can do with the resources that we’re receiving, and not just in the narrow sense of helping people immediately in need, but how can we change the structure of things.” Here are selected excerpts from his comments.
Topping the list of challenges facing Joe Lhota is his own party’s unity and support. While rival Bill de Blasio has methodically pulled his former rivals and their supporters onto his bandwagon, Lhota has had less success in uniting Republicans. Republicans are, of course, vastly outnumbered in New York City and even a unified party falls far short of what Lhota needs to win, but it’s a basic building block that Lhota has not yet put into place.
Since the primary de Blasio has received the public support of his top three Democratic primary rivals (Bill Thompson, Chris Quinn and John Liu), while also receiving the endorsement of three Democratic county organizations (Bronx, Queens and Manhattan) that did not support him in the primary. In contrast, Lhota has not received the endorsement of either of his primary rivals John Catsimatidis or George McDonald, and has only received a few additional public endorsements, with George Pataki, State Senate Republican leader Dean Skelos and New York County Chairman Dan Isaacs among them. Staten Island Borough President James Molinaro (who is a Conservative Party, not Republican Party, member and who endorsed Christine Quinn in the primary) has also endorsed Lhota.
Queens County is a stark illustration of Lhota’s challenge. The County Republican organization supported John Catsimatidis in the primary and appears unlikely to actively support Lhota. It’s split into two factions, one led by Chairman Phil Ragusa (supporting Catsimatidis) and the other composed of a mix of people bitterly opposed to Ragusa, including Council Member Eric Ulrich and former council member Tom Ognibene, as well as the now infamous John Haggerty and his brother Bart. Ragusa appears to have just won re-election as chairman over challenger, and former congressman, Bob Turner, whom Lhota supported. At a Friday press conference, Politicker’s Ross Barkan (who closely follows and reports on Queens politics) asked Lhota about the leadership battle, and Lhota responded with the following harsh critique of “Comrade Ragusa”. Based on Lhota’s comments, it appears that Queens County Republican Committee support for Lhota is, shall we say, not imminent.
(Note that the questions were at a press conference held before the vote for county chairman was completed. It’s subsequently been unofficially reported that Ragusa won re-election in Friday’s vote.)
Joe Lhota is solidly against the 91st Street marine transfer station, announcing that as mayor he will discontinue the City’s efforts at building it. Lhota appeared at a press conference this morning in front of Asphalt Green, the sports and arts facility immediately adjacent to the planned waste transfer station. Speaking to an enthusiastic crowd of 100 or so, it was one of the best Lhota campaign appearances that I’ve seen so far.
The transfer station is part of the City’s Comprehensive Solid Waste Management Plan, a large, complex plan which is more than a decade in the making. The SWMP grew out of the Giuliani-era closing of the Fresh Kills landfill, previously the destination for the City’s garbage, as the City has tried to develop a long term plan for waste transfer. Lhota is certainly knowledgable on the topic, having been involved in the Fresh Kills closing as Giuliani’s deputy mayor for operations.
In answering questions from the press, Lhota addressed some of the operational aspects of the City’s waste transfer plan, asserting that eliminating the 91st Street station and instead continuing to truck the affected trash to New Jersey would be less expensive and a better outcome. When asked why this was so important to him, Lhota gave several reasons, concluding by noting that he “expect[s] to live in a building right over here”, pointing toward Gracie Mansion. When questioned why as a Republican he would engage in “environmental activism”, he responded with a sense of outrage, saying that it is not just a Democratic issue and noting that a Republican president created the EPA (that would be Richard Nixon, but without noting, well, you can guess at all that he didn’t note).
Here is Lhota’s on-topic press Q&A from this morning.
The 91st Street marine transfer station was a topic of discussion during the primaries, with candidates split on what they would do about it. For some background, here is a discussion from a Bronx mayoral forum in June. It’s an issue that inflames many outside of Manhattan, who see it as efforts by a wealthy, well-connected neighbor to avoid the same burdens that they face.
Insight, analysis and reporting on New York and national politics